By BlueInk Staff
Seeking for inspiration in the new year?
Look no further than Allen Levi and his little book-that-could, Theo of Golden. Beginning life as a self-published novel, Theo of Golden took off, becoming one of 2025’s biggest selling books.
Levi wasn’t necessarily a good bet to become a literary sensation. His eclectic career has included working as a lawyer in Columbus, Georgia; studying Scottish fiction at the University of Edinburgh; traveling the country as a musician; and serving as a probate judge. In other words, he’s not your average Iowa Writers Workshop graduate.
But something clicked one day when he saw a group of portraits in a café. He purchased a few, and “over the course of the next few days and weeks, I would look at them and imagine what stories they might be trying to tell me,” he told the Washington Post.
The seeds for his blockbuster novel were sown.
Levi’s novel centers on an elderly man named Theo who is drawn to 92 pencil portraits he sees in a local coffee shop. “He begins purchasing them, one at a time, and putting them back in the hands of their ‘rightful owners.’ With each exchange, a story is told, a friendship born, and a life altered,” notes the book’s description on Amazon.
With the encouragement of friends and the help of his niece, Aron Ritchie, Levi self-published the novel in October 2023. A valiant effort to market the book ensued: Ritchie implored Levi’s friends and contacts “from various chapters of his life—childhood, college, music, his volunteer work reading to elementary-schoolers and working at a foster home” to “spread the word,” according to the Post. She wrote about Theo on Facebook. Meanwhile, Levi met with book clubs in person to push the book.
Their efforts quickly paid off: The book sold 3,000 copies by the end of 2023, 25,000 by the end of 2024, and soon, it was selling an eye-popping 1,000 copies a day. In October of 2025, Atria Books, an imprint of Simon & Schuster, acquired the book, beating out other publishers who bid on it.
“We’ll never know, this side of heaven, how all this connected,” Ritchie told the Post.
Others were less baffled: “Everyone around the business knew it was special,” Sean DeLone, an editor at Atria, told the Post. “Dovetailing with its author’s persona, the book’s message – of outreach to strangers, of small acts of generosity, of chance encounters unaided (and unhindered) by technology – turned audiences into evangelists.”
And the best detail of all? Levi was 69 when the book exploded last year.
Moral of the story: It’s never too late to aim high, as success is sometimes as close as that portrait hanging on a café wall.
Now get busy. That book isn’t going to write itself!
BlueInk Review offers serious, unbiased reviews of self-published and traditionally published books penned by writers drawn largely from major mainstream publications, such as The New York Times and Washington Post, editors of traditional publishing houses and high-profile blogs. Select reviews appear in Booklist magazine, a highly respected review publication that reaches 60,000 librarians. For more great tips about writing, publishing and marketing, sign up for our free newsletter.