Gordon R. Rawlyk adapts the scientific concept of “retrospective validation” to evaluate decisions he made as medical surrogate for his beloved, Rhonda, during the last two years of her life.
In this heartbreaking memoir, Rawlyk chronicles the time he spent caring for his partner Rhonda as she fought to recover from a failing heart. The two “battled through everything—the hospitalizations, the setbacks, the catastrophic COVID-19 pandemic, the lockdowns, the restrictions—all of it. But in the end, we lost,” he writes.
The struggle left the author physically, emotionally and spiritually altered, utterly alone, and questioning every difficult decision he had made regarding Rhonda’s care. Rawlyk states, “In my search for a way to audit the past I stumbled across a concept called ‘retrospective validation’”—a method of evaluating “past data and historical records to prove that an established process consistently produces products meeting predetermined specifications.” As a form of cathartic self-evaluation, Rawlyk applied this “technical concept from data science” to his memories of Rhonda’s care, trying to determine if he did all he could to save her.
Rawlyk painstakingly documents dates, times, locations and medical procedures that impacted Rhonda. Unfortunately, the quantity of tedious details bog down the story’s progression. Readers might find themselves wanting to skip over sections that either recap what they just read or aren’t crucial to the storyline, like: “I shut off the engine, unlocked the door, disarmed the alarm, and turned on the kitchen lights.”
More perplexing is Rawlyk’s decision to downplay a serious medical condition he was battling during Rhonda’s ordeal, not fully revealing the truth until the final section. It’s an odd choice considering it undermines the value of his retrospective validation and leaves readers feeling misled.
Rawlyk’s contribution serves as a detailed modern history of the difficulties many faced navigating serious medical conditions during the COVID-19 pandemic. Beyond that, it mostly accomplishes his personal need for catharsis and is unlikely to satisfy a wide audience.