Kaleidoscopic Quill

Edited by Demi Michelle Schwartz and Andie Smith

Visit Author Website

It can be called a rabble, flutter, swarm, or wing. Yet the most common word for a group of butterflies soaring in a colorful swirling pattern is kaleidoscope. This is the inspiration for Kaleidoscopic Quill, an anthology of poems, prose poems, and short stories centered on butterflies.

In some of the work, the connection is literal, such as Michelle Sanchez’s “Uncocooned,” where the speaker is a caterpillar narrating the process of transforming and bursting free. Others use butterflies more subtly, as mise en scene or plot device. In A. N. Griffith’s “The Book of Wings,” a highlight of the collection, a woman examines her dead mother’s book of butterfly specimens, remembering the shelf where it sat as “the one spot, the one thing, in our house that was beautiful.” Her mother had written a note beside each specimen, culminating with the last: “I wanted more for AnnaMae. She’ll break her chrysalis. I never could.”

Still other stories seem to force the butterfly connection. Bri Eberhart’s “An Email Never Sent” is an intriguing epistolary tale that ends with this out-of-nowhere analogy: “If you do see this, I hope you’re well […] Don’t mind me. I’ll be fine—just like the butterfly, I’ll find my new beginning.” It’s as if Eberhart suddenly realized she needed a nod to the anthology’s theme.

Change is the obvious theme of most of the poems. Some are accomplished; others less so. The first poem, “Who Will I Be?” by Dana Gricken, opens with “The future is unwritten/ A blank page in a history book/ But I wish I could peek ahead/ And take a quick look,” which feels unmetrical and clichéd. More proficient is E. H. Perry’s “Things With Feathers.” Written in quatrains, its slightly offbeat meter recalls Emily Dickinson’s work, to which Perry’s title refers.

Overall, Kaleidocopic Quill is an uneven collection. Still, with its inclusion of many styles — fantasy, romance, horror, magical realism, slice-of-life — it offers something for everyone.